Logics of Protection and the Discursive Construction of Refugee Fathers

Dr

Lucy Hall

Lucy asks questions about gender, violence and protection. From disasters and humanitarian response to gender-based violence both on and offline, Lucy’s work attempts to dig into deep conceptual layers, whilst maintaining a view to developing policy relevant findings.
Australian

Year of research: 2019

DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780190939182.003.0005

Connect on social media

Dr

Hall's Recommendations

  • Reflect on the images used for advocacy campaigns
  • Critically think about gender in relation to refugee protection
  • Contribute to challenging assumptions around gender, race and class

Recommended For:

Key Findings

In this chapter I turn my feminist curiosity towards a shift in media coverage of the migration, or refugee ‘crisis’ away from ‘womenandchildren’ (Enloe 1992) and towards ‘refugee fathers’. Through an intersectional approach I explore images of refugee fathers. This chapter contributes to existing work that has linked responsible parenting to deserving refugee-ness.

Based on my analysis, my findings suggest that ‘Middle Eastern’ men can only be rendered intelligible as deserving of protection in relation to their children and families. This construction reinforces not only essentialist hierarchies of masculinity and femininity, but hierarchical constructions of masculinities, organised by and through logics of race and sexuality. Linked to the logic of ‘deserving’ and ‘authentic’ refugee fathers is the construction of single, refugee men as dangerous and/or lacking courage and therefore not deserving of protection.

In other words, the construction of refugee fathers also leaves undisturbed the logics that inform the construction of single refugee men as threatening and/or cowardly. Non paternal refugee men are then rendered underserving of refugee protection. The consequence of this is that authentic refugee-ness can only be read onto the bodies of refugee men through the logic of paternal protection and responsibility. In other words, fatherhood constructs genuine refugee men through logics of paternity, responsibility and bravery.

Additional applications

Methodology

My approach does not distinguish between discourse as purely linguistic and discourse as image. In the analysis I treat the images and their attendant linguistic texts as discursive formations.

Attention needs to be paid to local context and nuance, however there are similar patterns of gender, race and class that interact with how refugee protection policy and practice is carried out.

Reference this research

Hall, Lucy. (2020). Logics of Protection and the Discursive Construction of Refugee Fathers. in Troubling Motherhood: Maternality in Global Politics.

Share these insights

Lucy.
(?).
Hall,

Dr

Lucy Hall

(She/Her)

Lecturer

Faculty of Law & Governance

University of Amsterdam

Year of research: 2019

DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780190939182.003.0005

Lucy asks questions about gender, violence and protection. From disasters and humanitarian response to gender-based violence both on and offline, Lucy’s work attempts to dig into deep conceptual layers, whilst maintaining a view to developing policy relevant findings.
Australian